Sam Ghandchiسام قندچيبازهم درباره جمهوری آینده نگر
سام قندچی

http://www.ghandchi.com/1439-jomhourie-ayandehnegar.htm

 

پانزده سال پیش طرح جمهوری آینده نگر ایران مطرح شد (1).

 

در آنزمان، دوستان آی پی سی، پادشاهی خواه بودند و بعدها به جمهوریخواهی رسیدند. دکتر ایکس که هم، آن زمان، و هم، امروز، هوادار جدی خدمات دو پادشاه پهلوی، و بویژه رضا شاه است، توضیح بسیار عالی در مورد اشتباه رضا شاه در پذیرفتن سلطنت بجای جمهوری، ارائه کرده است، و می گوید که رضا شاه جمهوریخواه واقعی بود (2).

 

دکتر ایکس می نویسد، اگر سلطنت مشروطه می توانست مشکل ایران را حل کند، یعنی پادشاه قدرتی نداشته باشد، سلطنت احمد شاه که دقیقاً همان بود، به نتیجه رسیده بود؛ اما، نتوانست موفق شود، و به همین دلیل، در آخرین روزهای سلطنت مشروطه قاجار، کشور بطور مداوم، در حال از هم پاشیدن بود (3).

 

اینکه این مطلب را می نویسم ابداً شروع بحث جمهوری و پادشاهی نیست، و به نظر دوستانی که همچنان معتقد به راهکار پادشاهی برای ایران آینده هستند، احترام می گذارم، و امید است، همچنان، بحث دوستانه ای را که سه هفته پیش، با شاهزاده رضا پهلوی، در مورد دو استراتژی مختلف، برای همکاری، مطرح شد، ادامه دهیم (4).

 

به امید جمهوری آینده نگر دموکراتیک و سکولار در ایران

سام قندچی، ناشر و سردبیر ایرانسکوپ
http://www.iranscope.com 
http://www.ghandchi.com
چهارم خرداد ماه 1396
May 24, 2017
 

پانویس:

 

1. چرا جمهوری آینده نگر مطرح شد
http://www.ghandchi.com/1256-why-futurist-republic.htm

 

2. Reza Shah the Great of Iran, Pahlavi I, The Real Story
http://iranpoliticsclub.net/history/reza-shah/index.htm 
 

...

Reza Khan was a true Republican, he wanted to establish a Republic in Iran and become the first president; however, the traditional combine institutes of the Persian Royal Courthouse, monarchists, Feudals and Shiite Mullahs saw their social classes benefits in danger and forced him to become a shah.
Reza Khan desired to be the first president of Iran and reform Iran. His desire was for the people to elect one worthy president after another and revive Iran. Reza Khan wanted a Secular Republic to cut off the hands of the Shiite Islam from the government. Deep inside, Reza Khan despised the corrupt institutes of monarchy, feudalism and religion.
The history would have been different and today’s Iran would have been heaven if Reza Khan had gotten his way! Unfortunately, the Monarchists, Mullahs and Feudals continued the tradition of dictatorship and eventually the Absolutist Monarchial Dictatorship gave birth to the Theocratic Shiite Dictatorship of the 1979. The Old Monarchist – Shiite Brotherhood tied Reza Khan’s hands and avoided the creation of the Democratic Republic of Iran; furthermore, they put Iran in a path of traditional tyranny which resulted in a Theocratic Dictatorship of IRI. Throughout the history of Iran, Monarchists and Mullahs have always gone hand in hand. Every time a true reformer wanted to develop a change, the Brotherhood of Monarchists and Mullahs have blocked it! If Reza Khan would have gotten his way, Iran’s destiny would have been different; Monarchy would seize to exist and IRI would have never been born!

 

3.Reza Shah the Great of Iran, Pahlavi I, The Real Story
http://iranpoliticsclub.net/history/reza-shah/index.htm 

....

From 1906 - 1909 the constitutional revolutionaries and constitutional monarchists such as Satar Khan and Baqer Khan shed blood and spent many efforts to establish a constitutional monarchy in Iran. During the reign of Ahmad Shah Qajar (1909 - 1925), Iran was the perfect example of a constitutional monarchy (European Style). Obviously the constitutional monarchy did not work in Iran because the nation became on the verge of collapse. Absolutist monarchy, also did not work in Iran, or else people would have not committed to a grand revolution to change it to a constitutional monarchy. So neither absolutist monarchy, nor constitutionalist monarchy could have worked in Iran. Both systems had their chances, both systems governed Iran and both systems failed miserably. No one was aware of this fact, better than Reza Khan. His goal was to end monarchy and create the first republic in Iran, the same as what Kemal Ataturk had done in Turkey. A Secular Nationalist Republic with Reza Khan as the first president would have been the desired system of government for Iran. This was Reza Khan's plan. His popularity was so high that he would have been elected for president surely for two consecutive terms. After him, would come one democratically elected president after another. This was Reza Khan's logical and rational plan for Iran

 

4. بحثی دوستانه با شاهزاده رضا پهلوی
http://www.ghandchi.com/1417-discussion-reza-pahlavi.htm
 

 

متون برگزیده
http://featured.ghandchi.com

 

 

 

 

SEARCH